Evolution of Transformer Winding Materials

—Balancing Cost and Performance: From Electrolytic Copper to Copper-Clad Aluminum

According to data from the International Copper Association (ICA), winding materials account for 35%-50% of a transformer's total cost. Over the past 30 years, copper prices have surged by 380%, driving global manufacturers to explore low-cost alternatives. From pure electrolytic copper to copper-clad aluminum (CCA), copper-clad steel (CCS), and nano-coated composite conductors, this material revolution has profoundly impacted the performance and economic efficiency of power equipment. This article analyzes the evolution and future trends of winding materials based on standards such as IEC 60076-7 and IEEE C57.18.10.

Content

1.The Era of Electrolytic Copper (1950–2000): The Gold Standard for Performance

● Characteristics and Structure:Electrolytic copper (purity ≥99.95%) is produced via electrolytic refining, featuring uniform lattice structures and ultra-low impurities. Its high free-electron density and low migration resistance provide two core advantages:

(1)Exceptional Conductivity: Conductivity up to 58.5×10⁶ S/m, reducing resistive losses (I²R) by 40% compared to aluminum.

(2)Superior Ductility: Can be drawn into 0.1mm filaments for complex winding structures, with creep resistance ensuring <0.2% deformation at 150°C.

● Value for Transformers:

(1)Low Losses: In 400kV ultra-high-voltage transformers, no-load losses remain <0.1% (per IEC 60076-1).

(2)Long Lifespan: A 400kV transformer manufactured by Siemens in 1978 still operates with losses 5% below design values after 43 years.

● Cost Challenges and Demand for Alternatives:Post-2000, copper prices skyrocketed from $0.6/kg to $9.8/kg (2022 peak), coupled with high carbon emissions from copper smelting (8.5t CO₂ per ton of copper). This pushed the industry to seek alternatives. Copper’s cost share in distribution transformers rose from 28% to 52%, accelerating demand for lightweight, low-cost solutions in developing countries’ grid expansion projects.

2. Copper-Clad Aluminum (CCA): Optimizing Weight and Cost 

● Material Composition and Manufacturing:Copper-clad aluminum (CCA) uses cold-rolling technology to bond a 0.15mm copper layer to an aluminum core (15:85 copper-aluminum ratio). Continuous extrusion ensures ±5μm thickness tolerance (EN 13602), while annealing eliminates interfacial stress. CCA withstands over 5,000 bending cycles (IEC 60213).

● Key Advantages:

(1)Lightweight: Density of 4.5g/cm³ (50% of pure  copper), reducing transport and installation costs.

(2)Cost-Effective: Material cost of $4.8/kg vs. $9.2/kg for pure copper, achieving 18% total cost savings.

(3)Conductivity Retention: 75%-82% IACS conductivity, meeting most distribution transformer needs (IEC 60076-7).

● Applications:

(1)Distribution Transformers: Tata Power’s 10MVA transformer in India reduced costs by 18% using CCA.

(2)Wind Farm Substations: 60% of global wind farm substations now use CCA windings.

3. Copper-Clad Steel (CCS) and Nano-Coatings: Breakthroughs for Extreme Conditions 

● Copper-Clad Steel (CCS): Enhanced Short-Circuit Resistance Structure: CCS embeds a carbon steel core (30%-40% diameter) within an aluminum matrix, forming a "copper-aluminum-steel" composite. The steel core provides ≥1200MPa tensile strength, while ≥0.1mm copper layers balance conductivity and mechanical durability.

(1)Advantages:

● Short-Circuit Resistance: Withstands 120kN/m electromagnetic force (IEC 60076-5), improving short-circuit tolerance by 60%.

● Cost Efficiency: Material cost of $5.1/kg, 25% lower than heavy-duty pure copper solutions.

(2)Applications:

● Ultra-High Voltage Projects: China’s ±1100kV Ji-Quan UHV project uses CCS for 63kA short-circuit resistance.

● Heavy Industries: ThyssenKrupp’s steel plant transformers in Germany reduced short-circuit failures by 45%.

● Nano-Coatings: Revolutionizing Corrosion Resistance Structure

A 50nm graphene-silica composite coating is applied via chemical vapor deposition (CVD). Graphene’s hexagonal lattice blocks moisture/oxygen, while silica enhances wear resistance.

(1)Advantages:

● Corrosion Resistance: Passes >3,000 hours in salt spray tests (ISO 9227), 3.75x better than pure copper.

● Low Contact Resistance: Coating reduces contact resistance to 0.15mΩ (ASTM B539), minimizing heat generation.

(2)Applications:

● Coastal Substations: Toshiba’s Yokohama substation in Japan extends equipment lifespan to 40 years.

● Offshore Wind Farms: Coated CCA reduces failures by 70% in salt spray environments, extending maintenance cycles from 2 to 5 years.

4. Comparative Performance of Winding Materials

In Summary

Conclusion Winding material innovation balances cost, performance, and sustainability:

● CCA delivers 80% performance at 60% cost, dominating distribution transformer markets.

● CCS offers 350MPa tensile strength, ideal for ultra-high-voltage short-circuit protection.

● Nano-coatings extend coastal equipment lifespan from 25 to 40 years. Future trends include carbon fiber (2.0g/cm³ density) and high-temperature superconductors, projected to slash costs by 40% by 2030 and accelerate global energy transitions.

Contact us

LuShan, est.1975, is a Chinese professional manufacturer specializing in power transformers and reactors for50+ years. Leading products are single-phase transformer, three-phase isolation transformers,electrical transformer,distribution transformer, step down and step up transformer, low voltage transformer, high voltage transformer, control transformer, toroidal transformer, R-core transformer;DC inductors, AC reactors, filtering reactor, line and load reactor, chokes, filtering reactor, and intermediate,high-frequency products.

Our power transformers and reactors are widely used in 10 application areas: rapid transit, construction machinery, renewable energy, intelligent manufacturing, medical equipment, coal mine explosion prevention , excitation system, vacuum sintering(furnace), central air conditioning.

Know more about power transformer and reactor :www.lstransformer.com.

If you would like to obtain customized solutions for transformers or reactors, please contact us.

WhatsApp：+86 13787095096
Email:marketing@hnlsdz.com